01What’s at stake
Compliance risks have markedly increased as the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) dramatically increases its I-9 and worksite enforcement efforts. The government is conducting more audits and investigations, and the potential risks and penalties for employers have increased as well.
Failures can expose an employer to:
- Civil penalties
- Discrimination claims
- Operational disruption
- Reputational harm
- Debarment from federal contracting
- In more serious cases, criminal liability
The bigger risk can be your workforce
Employers in industries with large hourly workforces, such as construction, agriculture, retail, restaurants, food services or processing, and temporary staffing, face additional significant risks in an ICE audit or investigation, well beyond penalties for I-9 paperwork violations.
Employee turnover could potentially have a much more severe impact on an employer’s business or operations than any fines for I-9 errors.
02Why a correct I-9 isn’t enough: identity and document fraud
Identity and document fraud are distinct risks that can undermine employment verification even when an employer follows the ordinary Form I-9 process. They show up in three ways:
AI-generated documents
Advances in generative artificial intelligence have made it easier to create counterfeit identity and work-authorization documents designed to survive a visual review.
Real identity, fake document
Genuine personal information obtained from a real individual can be paired with a forged or altered document, making inconsistencies harder to detect.
Valid-looking but revoked
A document may appear facially valid and unexpired even though the government has since revoked or invalidated the underlying employment authorization.
A properly completed Form I-9 does not establish that an identity was not stolen.
03When ICE calls: audits, investigations and penalties
A Form I-9 inspection generally begins when Homeland Security Investigations serves a Notice of Inspection (NOI). The NOI usually requests the I-9 forms for all active employees and any employees terminated in the past 12 months, for the entire business or a specific location.
What ICE looks for
ICE reviews the I-9 records to determine:
- Whether there is an I-9 for every employee
- Whether the I-9s were completed on time
- Whether the forms contain any errors or omissions
- Whether the documents presented by employees are valid
What it can cost
Paperwork fines
$288 to $2,861
per form that has at least one substantive error.
Knowing-hire fines
$716 to $5,724
per unauthorized worker for a first offense.
$0$6,000
Even for employers with no concerns regarding employment of unauthorized workers, those fines can quickly add up if the employer’s I-9 records are not in good condition.
04Your I-9 software can be included in the audit
Technology can dramatically improve an employer’s overall compliance with I-9 and E-Verify requirements. But the ICE regulations that allow electronic completion of I-9 forms include specific legal requirements those systems must meet, and in I-9 audits ICE is increasingly focused on the compliance of the electronic I-9 systems employers use.
Even with error-free forms
In several cases, ICE has imposed or is seeking to impose substantial penalties on employers because of alleged system flaws of commercial I-9 solutions, even where the actual I-9 forms did not contain any errors.
Also in the full guide
The full guide by Daniel Brown, ready to print or share with your legal and HR teams.
Page 3
I-9 vs. E-Verify: what’s the difference?
Page 5
The law behind the I-9: what is IRCA?
Page 6
How the I-9 works, step by step
Page 7
E-Verify: how it works and the rules that trip employers up
Page 10
What should you do if something doesn’t look right?
Page 13
How ICE reviews your I-9 system, and what to do before the Notice of Inspection arrives
Page 14
How audit-ready is your I-9 program? A 15-question scorecard
Get the full guide